Missouri regulators have sued the Vatican, alleging that Roman
Catholic Church officials conspired to launder millions of dollars
looted in one of the largest scandals to rock the U.S. insurance
industry.
Joining officials from four other states, the Missouri Department
of Insurance filed the federal lawsuit late Thursday in Jackson,
Miss., seeking to recover more than $200 million from the
Vatican.
The lawsuit stems from an alleged scam headed by financier Martin
Frankel, who is charged with racketeering in Connecticut. Frankel is
accused of buying insurance companies, including one registered in
Missouri, then siphoning the insurers' cash reserves and using them
to purchase mansions, cars, diamonds and gold.
He has pleaded not guilty and is awaiting trial.
Frankel fled to Germany in 1999 after Mississippi insurance
regulators began asking questions about a charity with ties to the
Vatican that Frankel had allegedly used as a "front" to purchase
insurance companies.
Randy McConnell, a spokesman for the Missouri Department of
Insurance, said suing the the Vatican was not a step the state took
lightly.
"There were people in the Vatican acting in a secular capacity
that helped facilitate Frankel and his scheme," McConnell said. "All
we are asking from this lawsuit is that the Vatican, in its secular
capacity, be held to the same standards as other people and
institutions."
The Vatican's embassy in Washington D.C., declined to comment and
referred questions to its press office in Rome, which was closed
Friday.
In a 1999 statement, however, the church said that neither the
charity nor another foundation that also is a defendant in the
lawsuit fell under the Vatican's jurisdiction.
According to the lawsuit, Frankel's connection to the church was
Monsignor Emilio Colagiovanni, a senior member of the Curia, or
Vatican government, and an appellate judge in the church courts. In
the late 1990s, Colagiovanni was the president of Monitor
Ecclesiasticus, a religious and charitable foundation that publishes
the decisions of Vatican courts.
Colagiovanni has been charged with wire fraud and money
laundering, and is free on bond.
His attorney, John R. Gulash, declined to comment on the lawsuit
or the charges against Colagiovanni.
According to the lawsuit, Frankel established a charity -- the
St. Francis of Assisi Foundation to Serve and Help the Poor and
Alleviate Suffering -- that he would use to acquire insurance
companies, using money that he already had looted in prior insurance
schemes.
Colagiovanni allegedly used his foundation to make it appear as
if St. Francis' funding came from Vatican sources, and assured
others that St. Francis was legitimate.
"(Colagiovanni) used his position as a member of the Curia to
convince state government officials and insurance companies in the
United States that St. Francis was connected with the Vatican
through Monitor Ecclesiasticus, and that St. Francis was a
Vatican-funded initiative," the lawsuit contends.
In return, Frankel agreed to transfer $5 million to a Monitor
Ecclesiasticus account that Colagiovanni controlled, according to
the lawsuit.
Colagiovanni also is alleged to have escorted executives from an
insurance company on a private Vatican tour to assure them that St.
Francis had received Vatican money.
The lawsuit further alleges that senior Vatican officials
approved the scheme and took no action to repudiate Colagiovanni's
misrepresentations.
"High-ranking officials at the Vatican authorized or ratified the
plan whereby Monitor Ecclesiasticus would be used as a conduit for
the flow of Frankel's money to St. Francis to purchase U.S.
insurance companies, which St. Francis claimed a `Vatican tie.'
"
The insurance commissioners of the five states are already
seeking more than $600 million in damages from Frankel in a lawsuit
filed in 2000. The latest lawsuit was filed under federal
racketeering statutes, which allow for actual damages to be tripled.
A final judgment in this case could top $600 million.
Missouri officials became involved in the case when a company
registered in the state, International Financial Services Life
Insurance Co., was declared insolvent in May 1999.
Frankel acquired International Financial Services through a
holding company in 1994. International Financial Services was
registered in Missouri but had no offices there. It was licensed to
provide modest burial plans in 40 states, but it had only one
licensed agent in Missouri.
Officials have estimated that the company lost $57 million in the
scam.